40
to govern the relationship between the participants and the TO. Firstly, this relationship may be
established using the contract of
mudarabah
. Under this contract, the participants, collectively
as the capital providers, entrust the TO, as the
mudarib
, to invest the
Takaful
contributions to
generate profits for the
Takaful
fund. Any profits from the investment will be shared between
the
Takaful
fund (participants’ portion) and the TO at a pre-agreed ratio.
Secondly, the contract of
wakalah
could also be used to govern this relationship. Under the
wakalah
model, the participants as the principals (
muwakkil
) appoint the TO as an agent (
wakil
)
to perform the specific tasks of managing and investing the
Takaful
fund on their behalf. The
contract of
wakalah
is very flexible; it could be applied for delegating either the management of
underwriting activities or investment of the
Takaful
fund or for both. As an agent who works on
a commercial basis, the company normally charges fees (
ujrah
) for their services. The amount
or rate of the fees must be fixed and agreed by the TO and the participant upfront.
Thirdly, the contract of
juʻalah
7
(reward) could also be used to govern the relationship between
the TO and the participants. In this contract, the participants appoint the TO to manage the
Takaful
fund to reach a certain level of performance, and a specific amount of reward or
commission will be paid to the TO if the required outcome is achieved. Under this arrangement,
the payment of reward or commission to the TO depends on the final result at the end of the
financial year. If the TO does not achieve the required outcome, it would not be entitled to get
the reward. In the operation of
Takaful
, the contract of
juʻalah
is typically used for the payment
of performance fee to the TO. The fee is paid as an incentive to the TO if there is a surplus in the
risk fund after deducting claims and expenses.
Finally, the relationship between the TO and the participants could also be governed by a
combination of two or all of the above-mentioned contracts. For example, the contract of
wakalah
could be used for the management of the
Takaful
fund and the contract of
mudarabah
used for the investment of the fund. Through this arrangement, the company charges a fixed fee
for the management of the fund and shares some portions of the investment profits with the
participants. Also, the contract of
juʻalah
could be added to provide incentives for the TO if it
could improve its performance to achieve specific outcomes.
3.2.
Takaful
Modus Operandi
The
Takaful
industry has developed significantly over the years and with the help of
Shari'ah
scholars some of whom are members of
Shari'ah
Boards, several
Takaful
models (non-
commercial and commercial models) have been developed.
Figure 3 classifies the models
according to the underlying contract, which clarifies how the TO is compensated for the
management of the
Takaful
fund. From the regulatory perspective, a major concern is how the
TO is compensated for its services. Every
Takaful
model defines the following aspects:
7
It is a contract of reward, a unilateral commitment to reward for a specific act or accomplishment.