32
that is prohibited due to the existence of
riba
,
gharar
and
maysir
. The resolution also indicated
that the
Takaful
and
Re-Takaful
activities must be supervised by a permanent
Shari'ah
Advisory
Board. Such
Takaful
and
Re-Takaful
operators are to adopt investment strategies which comply
with the
Shari'ah
and ensure they operate by utilizing modes of financing that are in line with
the
Shari'ah
principles and concepts (Benbouzid, 2005).
Since the early 1980s, there have been a lot of efforts and initiatives to develop the
Re-Takaful
operations and models that are
Shari'ah
-compliant and distinguishable from the conventional
reinsurance practices that are tainted with prohibited elements of
riba
,
gharar
and
maysir
. The
Shari'ah
-compliant operations have been introduced to replace the traces of all the three
prohibited elements (
riba
,
gharar
and
maysir)
that are substantially unavoidable in reinsurance.
The practice of conventional reinsurance involves
riba
in the contract between a cedant and a
reinsurer. This is questionable from the
Shari'ah
perspective because the ceded premiums being
invested by the reinsurer in financial instruments may contain elements of
riba
. The commission
in
Re-Takaful
, in contrast, does not depend on the investment of profit, but it is based on the
agreed
wakalah
fee for the services rendered by the
Re-Takaful
company. In addition, the
investment activities in
Takaful
and
Re-Takaful
are conducted in a
Shari'ah
-compliant manner
and free from any prohibited elements.
Gharar
and
maysir
relate with the element of ambiguity and gambling that must be eliminated
from a contract of sale whose existence and description of the items are not confirmed or where
there is asymmetric information leading to deception (El-Gamal, 2001). In a conventional
reinsurance contract, the reinsurer’s gain or profit is made from the premiums paid. In this case,
the beneficiary may not gain any profit, if there was no claim made during the contract period;
and thus, the element of uncertainty exists (Zuhayli, 1997). Distinctively, the
Takaful
and
Re-
Takaful
operations that are developed based on the concept of cooperation (
tabarru’
or
ta’awun
)
eliminate
gharar
and
maysir
. The operation of
Re-Takaful
is, in fact, a cooperative exercise in
which the TO contributes towards a pool of fund. The claims are then made from the fund and,
then, in case of underwriting surplus, all unclaimed profits (surpluses) are shared with the TOs
(Yusuf & Yuhasni, 2011).
Permissibility or Legality of
Takaful
There is no direct legal text in the Holy Qurʻan and/or the Sunnah on the permissibility or
non-permissibility of
Takaful
, but there are many legal texts in the Qur’an and prophetic
precedents (
hadith
) that encourage the spirit of
Takaful
which is based on cooperation,
shared responsibility, joint indemnity, common interest and solidarity. Allah the Almighty
said:
“
And help ye one another in righteousness and piety but help ye not one another in sin
and rancour, and fear Allah for Allah is strict in punishment
” (Qur’an, Surah al-Maidah,
5:2)