Improving Transport Project Appraisals
In the Islamic Countries
70
Figure 3.3: Responsible parties for preparing transport project appraisals
Source: survey
Quality review is another important aspect of project appraisals. The majority of the
respondents indicated that an internal department of the Ministry is responsible for the quality
review. In 25% of the cases, the quality review is also done by an external
institution/organisation, as illustrated i
Figure 3.4: Responsible party of quality review of project appraisals
Source: survey
Thirty-eight percent of the respondents indicated that project appraisal reports are made
publically available. It was also found that it is more common to conduct an informal stakeholder
consultation outside the parliamentary process, rather than a formal stakeholder consultation
through parliamentary processes. Moreover, local governments and sector organisations are
involved in the stakeholder consultation, while households are not.
27%
9% 64%
Public agencies Private consultants and universities Both
75%
25%
Internal department of Ministry External institution/organisation