Facilitating Trade:
Improving Customs Risk Management Systems
In the OIC Member States
98
The highest average rate of selectivity on the green channel belongs to Palestine with 81.21%
and Indonesia with 54.20% respectively. Morocco with 0% has the lowest average selectivity
rate on the green channel, Albania 82.09%, and Jordan with 33.93% respectively.
The lowest average selectivity rate on the yellow channel is in Ivory Coast with 5.52% and in
Palestine with 9.39%.
Among 8 OIC MS, Nigeria with 81.52% have the highest average selectivity rate on the red
channel (physical check of goods and documentary control), Ivory Coast with 55.02% and Togo
with 52.36%. Palestine, Indonesia, and Albania have the lower selectivity rates on the red
channel with 9.39%, 9.55%, and 10.13% respectively.
4 out of 8 OIC MS CAs reported data on the orange channel, indicating that the shipment/means
of transport selected for scanning gamma ray or x-ray. The highest average selectivity rate on
the orange channel belongs to Albania with 6.11%, Ivory Coast with 4.06%, Nigeria 1.99%, and
Indonesia with the lowest rate of 0.30%. Many of the CAs worldwide, includes the orange
channel in the yellow or red channel with the instruction to scan the shipments or means of
transport. In particular, this is the case of the CAs that are using ASY++ or AW CDPS. Therefore,
the additional research should be performed on CRM selectivity practice.
The selectivity on the blue channel, indicating that the trader selected for post-clearance audit
is in use in 3 out of 8 OIC MS. Indonesia has the highest average rate of selectivity on the blue
channel with 14.92% and Togo with the lowest rate of 6.18%. The
Figure 34 presents the
average selectivity rate of the 8 OIC MS CAs for the period of 2014 – 2016 by channel:
Figure 34: Average selectivity rate by channel 2014-2016
Author’s compilation based on the CRM Survey results
The highest selectivity rate is on the red channel with 33.80% in average, yellow with 34.45%,
green channel with 27.43% in average. The average rate on the blue channel is 2.64%, the lowest
selectivity rate is on the orange channel with 1.56%.
Table 22present the details on OIC MS
average selectivity rate for 2014-2016.
24,50%
36,14%
35,57%
0,91%
2,76%
28,53%
35,94%
32,11%
0,65%
2,64%
29,27%
31,28%
33,71%
3,11%
2,51%
0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 30,00% 35,00% 40,00%
Green Channel
Yellow Channel
Red Channel
Orange Channel
Blue Channel
2016
2015
2014